Summative assessment versus formative assessment is the topic of our blog post today!
Navigating the realm of educational assessments can seem like a tightrope walk. On the one hand, we have formative assessments, those continuous checks that help us modify our teaching and help students direct their learning. On the other hand, there are summative evaluations, which act as a final verdict on what a student has grasped. But how are they different and when should you use one over the other?
I have examined some compelling resources, including that of Frey and Fisher.Literacy 2.0” and insights from the Eberly Center, to give you a detailed guide that breaks down the essentials. Whether you are an experienced educator or a parent trying to understand your child’s academic journey, this post is your roadmap to understanding formative and summative assessments.
Frey and Fisher’s perspective
In their book, Frey and Fisher argue for a balanced approach. They emphasize that formative assessment is like your GPS during a road trip: it helps you make timely adjustments, whether to reroute or change speed. You are basically “assessing to learn.” On the other hand, summative evaluation is its final destination, a comprehensive look at what has been learned or “learning evaluation.”
Eberly Center Knowledge Collection
I also contributed some more reflection from the Eberly Center The page of. Depending on your resources, formative assessments are continuous and can take the form of real-time feedback, quizzes, or class discussions. Summative assessments, on the other hand, are generally high-stakes and include final exams, standardized tests, and end-of-unit projects.
Take personal
In my years in the classroom and in my current research work, I have found formative assessments to be a lifesaver. Not only do they measure where students are, but they also give me information as an educator to modify my teaching techniques. I remember a time when a quick, formative quiz revealed that the majority of the class was struggling with a concept. It allowed me to adapt my lesson plans again on the spot. Summative assessments are also vital, don’t get me wrong. They offer a holistic view of a student’s skills and knowledge, but should never be the sole focus of attention.
Various points of view
Of course, the debate around formative versus summative assessments is nuanced. Some educators argue that formative assessments can create a continuous feedback loop, allowing for a more student-centered environment. However, critics often point out that too many formative assessments can lead to “assessment fatigue” for both teachers and students.
Summative assessment versus formative assessment
To break it down, I’ve created a visual aid to serve as a quick guide for both of you. The image details the key differences and shows examples so you can easily understand how each fits into your teaching strategy.
Final thoughts
There we have it: the ins and outs of formative versus summative assessments. Both have their unique strengths and challenges, but it is their combined use that creates a comprehensive educational experience. Formative assessments are like your trusted co-pilot, giving you real-time feedback to correct course, while summative assessments are your final destination, offering a complete overview of the journey. From my time in the classroom and my current research, it is clear that a balanced approach is key to maximizing student success and fostering effective teaching strategies.
Sources:
Other readings
If you want to dive deeper into this, check out this list of books on formative assessment. These readings will give you a more complete understanding and offer theoretical foundations and practical applications.
